10 Best Screw Extractors of 2021【Buying Guide】

best screw extractors

It is quite frustrating to deal with old rusted bolts and screws often present in the old furniture. Removing these screws is not easy, especially for a DIY user, as it can create all sorts of problems if not extracted with the right tool. Moreover, the best screw extractor might be different for everyone, depending upon user requirements.

I will review the top 10 best screw extractors you can use to run your projects smoothly. By using these extractors, you can easily remove screws from any surface.

Best Screw Extractors 2021

ProductProduct NameRating
IRWIN Master Screw Extractor (10/10)
Vampire Screw Extraction Vampliers (9.5/10)
Alden Grabit Screw Extractor (9.5/10)
Ares Bolt/Stud Extractor Tool (9/10)
Rocketsocket Extraction Socket Set (9/10)
Alden Micro Broken Bolt Extractor (9/10)
 Neiko Screw Extractor And Left Hand Drill Bit Set(8.5/10)
Comoware Screw Extractor Set(8/10)
Elitexion Screw Extractor Remover Set (7.5/10)
IRWIN Bolt Extractor Set (7/10)

1. IRWIN Master Screw Extractor

  • Great Quality
  • Fast and efficient extractor
  • Easily removes damaged and worn-out screws

This set of screw extractors is made by one of the best manufacturers, making it impossible not to include in the list of best screw extractor sets. Irwin Hanson Master Extraction Set includes three different types of extractors. Furthermore, it has 6 spiral flute extractors,13 bolt extractors,16 left-hand cobalt drill bits, and 13 multi-spline extractors for a total of 48 pieces.

The spiral flute extractors are ideal for regular screws and bolts, while the bolt extractors can help remove exposed fasteners like bolts, nuts, or partially tightened screws. Finally, the multi-spline ones are suitable for applications that require a high or low torque profile. 

The feature which makes it appealing is that it doesn’t only include the most commonly used sizes, but also different types of extractors.

Pros

  • Deliver high torsion power
  • Convenient and indexed storage
  • Includes special drill bits for boring into metal

Cons

  • Its plastic case is fragile

2. Vampire Screw Extraction Vampliers

  • Ergonomic Handle
  • Lightweight design
  • High-quality plier with serrated jaws

Vampliers are easy to handle and preferred by many semi-professionals as it does not require any drilling. These are made in Japan out of carbon steel. Moreover, they are one of the best-broken bolt extractors as they have sharp jaws that can get a grip on a small part of a bolt sticking out of the material.

This extractor comes in various sizes you can choose according to your requirement. Not only that, but they are also quite useful for gripping the hardware with small surface area to grip like bolts. Lastly, it’s also a top extractor for stripped screws you can easily remove using vampliers.

Pros

  • Minimal extraction time
  • Constructed from durable material
  •  Use this on corroded, rusted, and stripped screws

Cons

  • The handle covers may slip off

3. Alden Grabit Screw Extractor

  • Easy to use
  • Made from high-quality steel
  • Tempered twice for extra hardness

Alden Grabit Pro is best for those who frequently work with wood and metal screws and strip them from time to time. This extractor is one of the best-broken screw kits made from M2 high-speed steel and delivers the best results. Moreover, there are four Grabit Pro bits of different sizes, which comes inside a storage case for your convenience.

The feature which differentiates it is that it does not require any separate set of drills. Furthermore, the set covers the whole range of screw size necessary to encounter most of the situations.   

Pros

  • Self-centering drill tip
  • Multiple tools not required
  • Two-step drill bit and extractor in one tool

Cons

  • Bits get a little bit dull after multiple uses

4. Ares Bolt/Stud Extractor Tool

  • Lifetime warranty
  • Chrome finish for additional rust protection
  • Made of high graded heat-treated alloy steel

These extractors are designed ideally to remove regular and broken stud bolts. Unlike traditional extractors that come in fixed sizes, this one is adjustable. Furthermore, it comes with a chuck that can fit between ¼” and ½” studs, nuts, bolts, and so on.

This tool has a hexagonal flat, which we can use with flat and adjustable wrenches. Moreover, it is a high-quality alloy extractor, which increases its longevity. Because of all these features, this product qualifies as one of the best-damaged screw extractors.

Pros

  • Durable, adjustable extractor
  • High tendency to strip the screws
  • Comes in different flexible sizes

Cons

  • Not very useful with ½” studs

5. Rocketsocket extraction socket set

  • Impact Strength
  • Professional standard
  • Superior removal technology

Rocketsocket is an American product that comes with razor grip technology. This technology allows it to have a firm grip on the screw, meaning no slipping and no busted knuckles. Moreover, each piece of this kit is made from high-quality steel, increasing its life span.

The set includes an extractor for all of the nuts and bolt sizes you will commonly encounter. Moreover, if you are looking for the best-stripped screw extractor, try this set it can easily remove stripped pan head screws. It is a slightly expensive product, but it is handy and justifies its value of money.

Pros

  • Warranty product
  • Easily extract rusted, stripped, and frozen screws
  • Proven Razor Grip technology with a firm grip

Cons

  • Slightly expensive product

6. Alden Micro Broken Bolt Extractor

  • Best for a small screw
  • Self-centering drill tip
  • No walking or wandering

If you are working with small stripped screws, which are generally present in electronics, you require the best-striped screw remover of the Alden Grabit Micro Broken Bolt Extractor. These extractors come in four different sizes. Moreover, you can easily remove screws sized between 3mm to 6mm from any material with this set.

These bits have two features:a self-centering drill bit and an excellent extractor. Each bit is reversible and can be used along with an adjustable chuck. Moreover, it comes with a storage case for easy portability.

In my experience, it is the best screw extractor for small screws. This kit is manufactured in America with high-quality steel. Lastly, this kit is extremely durable and provides a clean and smooth screw extraction.

Pros

  • It comes with a convenient holder 
  • Works on jagged, uneven rough breaks
  • The serrated extracting end for hard to remove bolts 

Cons

  • Tough to handle, make sure you drill slowly with it

7. Neiko Screw Extractor and Left Hand Drill Bit Set

  • Variety of sizes
  • Ease in application
  • Made from cobalt fortified high steel for increased service life

Neiko screw extractor is a strong candidate for the best screw extractor. It comes with 10 durable pieces along with drill bits. Moreover, they are constructed using top-end durable steel material, which provides a strong grip on screws.

This product has spiral flutes, which removes both loose and jammed fasteners. It comes in various sizes ranging from 5/64” to 19/64”. Lastly, if you are looking for a decent screw & bolt extractor set at an affordable price, Neiko is a good option.

Pros

  • High Grip as torque is applied
  • Spiral flutes dig deeper into the screws
  • Stored in a durable metal index carrying case

Cons

  • Not preferable with heavy-duty jobs

8. Comoware Screw Extractor Set

  • High-quality carbide material
  • Made with spiral flutes and straight shanks
  • Decreases the nominal thickness of the cutting layer

The Comoware Screw Extractor Set is convenient and versatile. You’ll have no difficulty removing broken screws and bolts with this handy set. Moreover, it’s the best easy out bolt extractor set when dealing with damaged pieces of the bolt as it easily removes them without harming the surface.

They’re made out of alloy steel and feature spiral grooves that can reach deep into a broken fastener to remove studs, screws, and even bolts. Lastly, the unique design improves heat dissipation while you work and helps ensure the extractors last a long time.

Pros

  • Remove chippings clearly
  • Extractors are 118-degree in angle 
  • Provides easy cutting and ultimately extraction

Cons

  • Not readily available in market check online stores

9. Elitexion Screw Extractor Remover Set

  • Heavy-duty screw extractors
  • Heat-treated hi-grade steel
  • Requires less effort

Elitexion Screw Extractor Remover Set is an excellent option for heavy-duty applications. Exceptionally stubborn screws and broken fasteners are much easier to remove with this extra-tough and robust set. Also, it includes six heavy-duty screw extractors in size ranging from 1/8” to ¾” in size.

 The set is an excellent choice for house, automotive, and construction applications. Elitexion is the best easy out screw extractor as it is quick, easy to use, and strong enough to handle whatever comes in its way. Furthermore, each screw extractor is made out of heat-treated high-grade steel, and they’re all packaged in an organized plastic storage case.

Pros

  • Budget-friendly
  • Works exceptionally well with stubborn screws
  • Ideal for removing pipe bolts, studs, and broken screws

Cons

  • Extractors are not labeled well

10. IRWIN Bolt Extractor Set

  • Affordable price
  • Superior durability
  • Made with high carbon steel

Irwin tools Hanson bolt-grip is an exceptional broken bolt extractor kit. The set comes with five pieces and different sizes ranging from 11mm to 5/8” in size. Furthermore, these bits are made of high carbon steel for superior durability.

These extractors have reverse spiral flutes designed to bite into a rounded bolt head for incredible grip power on even painted or rusted fasteners. Moreover, they have used these extractor sockets on a wide range of problem bolts, including some that could have led to costly repair bills.

Pros

  • Reverse spiral flutes
  • Universal lobular design
  • Maximum gripping power

Cons

  • The case lacks good padding and the tools might bounce inside

Now that you have plenty of options, it is time to choose the right brand.

Buying Guide

When it comes to picking the best screw extractor, there is a criterion. Follow these steps and choose the product which is perfect according to your need and requirement.

Fastener Size:

If screw extraction is a large part of your job, it is best to get a screw extractor set with different extractor types. These will enable you to remove screws of different sizes. Although, make sure these sizes are well-suited with the screws you want to remove.

Some sets can extract all kinds of bolts and screws no matter their size, while others lack this universal feature and can only be used on a limited number of fasteners.

Quality:

The more important criteria to consider was the quality of the product. One way to guess a product’s quality is by looking at the reputation of the brand that makes it. Nowadays, broken bolt extractors are made of premium quality materials such as hardened steel and titanium.

The best bolt extractors are made from superior quality hard steel, increasing its longevity.

Gripping Power

Some screw extractors bite the screws to provide a high amount of gripping power. Be sure to get an extractor made from high-grade steel, as this enhances the grip. Moreover, a suitable extractor needs to increase the gripping power as the resistance increases.

If you are looking for the best-broken screw extractor, make sure it has high gripping power because it creates a difference between an average and a good extractor.

Price:

Lastly, price is one of the critical criteria. In most cases, the best quality product is available at a high price and justifies its value. Although, if you are short on a budget, there are many products available in the market like Elitexion Screw Extractor Remover Set, which is affordable and delivers the best results.

Advantages of a Bolt Extractor

Broken bolt extractor has its advantages, especially for handymen, carpenters, or homeowners who are continually working on home improvement projects. Screw extractors are handy tools to remove rusted screws and stripped bolts in addition to other stubborn fittings.

They are incredibly convenient if you have a series of challenging broken screws embedded in metal or woodwork. Moreover, these broken fasteners can put a damper on your project and will require a smooth extraction, so they do not end up damaging your precious work piece.

Lastly, you can use these with different materials without causing any damage to their delicate surface.

With these you can learn how to screw into concrete.

To get the best forstner bits, you need to check these reviewed bits right here.

How to use a Screw Extractor

I will recommend wearing safety goggles to avoid any risk as this task requires drilling and cutting into the screws.

  • The first thing you need to do is create a small indentation in the center of the screw, and this is done by lining up the center of the stripped or broken screw with the center punch before lightly hitting it with a hammer.
  • Secondly, choose a drill bit with a smaller diameter than the broken screw so that you can attach it to the power drill. You can achieve more effortless drilling by adding a small drop of thread cutting oil to this broken fastener’s head. Moreover, if the screw you need to remove is stuck to a piece of metal, adding a drop of penetrating oil to the threads will help loosen its grip.
  • In the third step, line up the drill bit with a pierced area on the screw head. Now start drilling make sure you align the bit straight with the screw. The drilling depth varies according to the size of the screw extractor you anticipate to use, but it is usually around 1/8 to 1/4 inches deep.
  • In the final step, you will place the tip of your stripped bolt remover into the hole you created. Here a wrench or drill will come in handy depending on the type of extractor that you have chosen for this particular task. Moreover, you can use this drill or wrench to twist the tool counterclockwise. 

This twisting motion will enable the threads to burrow deeply into the hole. Once the extractor becomes deeply entrenched in the screw, you can then resume the counterclockwise twisting motion from before to entirely remove the stripped or broken fastener.

Alongside that, it is essential for us to understand the difference between a screw gun vs. impact driver.

Nonetheless, if you can simply fix a stripped screw using this guide.

Conclusion:

In conclusion, if you are a DIY user and searching for screw extractors, these are 10 of the best screw extractors available in the market. They will help you remove all kinds of screws, including damaged and broken ones. 

I will recommend getting the Irwin Tools Hanson Master Extraction Set in combination with Vampliers. Although, if you are on a budget, Elitexion Screw Extractor Remover Set is a great choice, too, as it’s an affordable and quality product.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best screw extractor?  

All the products mentioned in this article are the best. However, it depends upon your budget and needs, but the most high-rated screw extractor is the Irwin Hanson screw extractor. 
Besides that, you can how to unscrew a screw if you do not want to extract it.

What type of material are the extractors made of?

High carbon steel is the material of choice for extractors. There are three types of carbon steel: low, medium, and high. We often use High carbon steel to make bolt extractor sockets. There are screw driver bits as well, which will be of great help.

How do I know which size extractor to use?

Quality brands know just how important this step is and have chosen to share as much information as possible to help the consumer extract the damaged fasteners with ease. A detailed size chart is usually present inside the extractor case.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *